|
|
Propaganda can be classified
according to the source and nature of the message.
White
propaganda generally
comes from an openly identified source, and is characterized by gentler methods
of persuasion, such as standard public relations techniques and one-sided
presentation of an argument.
Black
propaganda often
pretends to be from a friendly source, but is actually from an adversary. Black
propaganda is characterized by its presentation of false information to elicit
a desired response, and is often used in covert military psychological
operations and by large networked organizations such as terror networks or
governments.
Gray propaganda may come from an adversarial source
pretending to be friendly or neutral, and presents misleading information in a
more insidious manner than white propaganda. In scale, these different types of
propaganda can also be defined by the potential of true and correct information
to compete with the propaganda. For example, opposition to white propaganda is
often readily found and may slightly discredit the propaganda source.
Opposition to gray propaganda, when revealed (often by an inside source), may
create some level of public outcry. Opposition to black propaganda is often
unavailable and may be dangerous to reveal, because public cognizance of black
propaganda tactics and sources would undermine or backfire the very campaign
the black propagandist supported.
Psychological
Operations (PSYOP)
"Capture their minds and
their hearts and souls will follow"
Psychological
Operations or PSYOP are planned operations to convey selected information and
indicators to audiences to influence their emotions, motives, objective
reasoning, and ultimately the behavior of organizations, groups, and
individuals. Used in all aspects of war, it is a weapon whose effectiveness is
limited only by the ingenuity of the commander using it.
A
proven winner in combat and peacetime, PSYOP is one of the oldest weapons in
the arsenal of man. It is an important force protector/combat multiplier and a
non-lethal weapons system.
Psychological
Operations (PSYOP) or Psychological Warfare (PSYWAR) is simply learning
everything about your target enemy, their beliefs, likes, dislikes, strengths,
weaknesses, and vulnerabilities. Once you know what motivates your target, you
are ready to begin psychological operations.
Psychological
operations may be defined broadly as the planned use of communications to
influence human attitudes and behavior ... to create in target groups behavior,
emotions, and attitudes that support the attainment of national objectives. The
form of communication can be as simple as spreading information covertly by
word of mouth or through any means of multimedia.
A
psychological warfare campaign is a war of the mind. Your primary weapons are
sight and sound. PSYOP can be disseminated
by face-to-face communication, audiovisual means (television), audio media
(radio or loudspeaker), visual media
(leaflets, newspapers, books, magazines and/or posters). The weapon
is not how it’s sent, but the message it carries and how that message affects
the recipient.
For
instance, our American flag, when it goes by in a parade do you feel a sense of
pride? How about when you hear our national anthem played? How about "God Bless the USA", Lee Greenwood's
song which became popular during Desert Storm? Music or sound can be a major
factor in motivating emotion if it is associated with the right message. How
many of you think about the pottery wheel scene with Patrick Swayze and Demi
Moore in the movie "Ghost"
when you hear the theme song "Unchained
Melody"?
It
has long been said that: "The pen is
mightier than the sword". That is because, if used properly, words can
be an inspiration to motivate others.
Some examples:
|
|
"Remember the
"Give me liberty or give me death"
"I regret I have but one life to give for my country"
"Ask not what your country can do for you? Ask what you can do for your
country"

Now
for psychological operations to be effective, you must carefully plan your
propaganda. You must make sure that you know everything about your
enemy and that you are targeting his beliefs and not using your own. For
example, at the very beginning of Desert Shield, just after
|
|
For
Americans and most of
On
the reverse side, knowing your enemy's beliefs can work for you. For example,
remember when Saddam Hussein broadcasted live images of his "Human
Shields, the woman and children of westerners that were in
How
do you get to know your enemy? Intelligence reports, Area studies, in country
research, defectors, native help, and even the enemy prisoners of war all are
sources of information. As leaflets were developed during Desert Storm, they
were tested on cooperative EPWs (enemy prisoners of war. Some of the
recommendations for changes to the leaflet's illustrations made by these EPWs
were: remove any trace of the color red (a danger signal to Iraqis), show
Allied soldiers with chin beards rather than clean-shaven faces (beards convey
trust and brotherhood in Iraqi culture), and add bananas to a bowl of fruit
shown being offered to surrendering Iraqis (bananas are a great delicacy in
Iraq). Also, an illustration
depicting a surrendering Iraqi thinking of his family back home confused the
EPWs. "Thought bubbles" are well known in Western culture, but
virtually unknown to Iraqis. The illustration was dropped.
In
a memo written to then-Secretary of State John Foster Dulles on 24 October
1953, former U.S. President Dwight D. Eisenhower defined psychological warfare
as anything "from the singing of a
beautiful anthem up to the most extraordinary kind of physical sabotage."
Used
during peacetime, contingencies and declared war, these activities are not a
form of force, but are force multipliers that use nonviolent means in often
violent environments. Persuading rather than compelling physically, they rely
on logic, fear, desire or other mental factors to promote specific emotions,
attitudes or behaviors. The ultimate objective of
Now
please note that I stated above that Psychological Operations as conducted by
the US Military is the dissemination of "truthful" information, not
propaganda which is categorized as "white, grey, or black". Now what
is the difference between psyops and propaganda? A memorandum prepared by the
Chief of Army Field Forces at Fort Monroe, Virginia in September of 1953
briefly explained the difference between "gray" propaganda, messages
broadcast with the goal of "avoiding identification," and
"black" propaganda, which involves "attribution to a source
other than the true one."
A
more recent set of definitions, reportedly used by former CIA chief William
Colby and cited in at least one commercial publication, calls
truthfully-attributed and non- attributed messages "white"
propaganda, whereas messages falsely attributed to a third party are considered
"gray." The term "black propaganda" is reserved for those
materials "planted by the
Now
Psychological Operations (PSYOP) is not a new military tactic by any means.
There are numerous examples of the use of psychological warfare throughout
history.
Perhaps
one of the earliest examples of Psychological Warfare was attributed to
"Alexander the Great of Macedonia. Alexander had conquered most of the
known world during his reign. With each region he conquered he left behind
soldiers to keep control of the newly conquered area. Eventually, there came a
point when Alexander realized that he had stretched his army too thin and was
now in danger of losing to a large opposing force. Alexander's only option was
to retreat and regroup forces with the armies he left behind. However, to do so
would certainly incite the opposing force to pursue him and very possibly
capture or defeat his now smaller army.
Alexander
knew that if he could intimidate the opposing force they would be scared to
follow his army. Alexander instructed his armoires to make several oversized
armor breastplates and helmets that would fit "giants", men 7 to 8
feet tall. As Alexander and his forces withdrew during the night they left
behind the oversized armor. The oversized armor was of course found by the
opposing force who then believed that they had come close to engaging in a
battle with giants. A battle that they surely would have lost. The oversized
armor coupled with the stories they had heard from travelers of the savagery of
Alexander's army caused enough doubt and fear that they elected not to pursue
Alexander's army.
Sun Tsu,
recognized as one of the greatest military tacticians of all times, strongly
advocated the use of psychological warfare as a force multiplier. Sun Tsu wrote
that:
"To
capture the enemy's entire army is better than to destroy it; to take intact a
regiment, a company, or a squad is better than to destroy them. For to win one
hundred victories in one hundred battles is not the acme of skill. To subdue
the enemy without fighting is the supreme excellence. Thus, what is of supreme
importance in war is to attack the enemy's strategy. Next best is to disrupt
his alliances by diplomacy. The next best is to attack his army. And the worst
policy is to attack cities.
Sun
Tzu understood that given the opportunity, an adversary will surrender to a
superior commander prior to conflict. In order to have a chance to be that
superior leader, PSYOP must be coordinated and included in initial planning and
implemented prior to conflict. If hostilities begin, proper PSYOP
implementation can end the conflict earlier than otherwise expected. PSYOP is a
force multiplier and resource saver.
Mongol leader Genghis Khan was widely known for leading
hordes of savage horsemen across
All these actions caused a weakness in their enemy's psyche,
and the Mongols were feared wherever they went.
World
War II
Tactical
deception had significant positive impacts on the success of Operation
Overlord, and, thus the retaking of the European continent in World War II.
Deception worked hand in hand with OPSEC to keep the organization and location
of the real Overlord cantonments, training sites, dumps, movements, and
embarkations carefully hidden. Unbelievable effort was put into creating mock
airfields and ports, phony ships, boats, planes, tanks, vehicles, and troop
movements, both real and staged. A new era of deception was introduced-the
electronic one. German coastal defense radars were destroyed in a calculated
pattern. Deception planners purposely left some intact in the
The
night the invasion was launched, the Allies began massively jamming German
radars with chaff. But they purposely did not completely cover their targets.
German radar operators could "see" between Allied jamming curtains.
And, what they saw was a ghost fleet of small ships towing barges and blimps
headed for
|
|
Psychological
operations were used extensively by all sides during World War II. Adolph
Hitler rose to power by exploiting the dissatisfaction of supporters of the
traditional left and right wing parties, by dwelling on the failure of these
parties to solve the problems created by the conditions imposed on
Radio
broadcasts became a major means of passing propaganda to the enemy.
However
the best and most innovative use of psychological warfare must be attributed to
a radio broadcast by the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC). A BBC radio
announcer made the following broadcast at a time when the Germans were making
plans to invade
The text of the
broadcast went something like this:
"Attention Jerries (British
slang for the German soldier).
Since you are preparing to invade our country
it is important that you learn some English phrases.
Please Repeat after me, The Channel Crossing, The Channel Crossing.
Very good, now some words you will find helpful
while you are on the boat.
"The boat is sinking",
"The boat is sinking".
Again very good! Now, let's practice the conjugation of verbs.
Now repeat after me.
"I am burning", "You are burning", "We are
burning".
Documents
found after the war showed that as a result of this broadcast, the German High
Command believed that the British had a workable plan to set fire to the
Having
learned the effectiveness of radio broadcasts and leaflets during World War II,
the U.S. Army Far East Command's small Special Projects Branch of the
Headquarters G-2 (Intelligence) Division, began radio broadcasts and leaflet
drops over the
The
1st Loudspeaker and Leaflet Company used both vehicle and aircraft mounted
loudspeakers to get their verbal messages across. However, as in previous

Psychological
Operations were used by both sides. Many G.I.'s may remember the notorious "Hanoi
Hannah", who like "Tokyo Rose" of WW II broadcasted a
daily radio program where she played music, coupled with the North's view of
the news and messages of discouragement to our troops.
The
Americans countered with their own radio broadcasts, and leaflet
programs.
In
These
air attacks failed to deter the communists from protracting the fighting for
over eight years in
·
access to support and sanctuary from
external powers, which allowed the enemy to continue fighting even when its
indigenous war-related production facilities had been destroyed.
·
strong commitment to the objectives or
cause that gave rise to the conflict with the
·
readiness to absorb enormous human and
materiel losses.
·
ability to maintain domestic support
for the war effort and/or sufficient internal security to suppress any
potential opposition.
·
perception that the likely benefits
from continued conflict would exceed the costs resulting from the
After
having already made what it considered to be its maximum feasible concessions
in the
Severe
The
communists agreed to terms only after their military forces on the battlefield
had been stalemated. Prior to the settlements, the communist forces in
Operation Just Cause -
At
H-Hour, 1-508th Abn had the mission of securing
The Gulf War
The
Gulf War brought a whole new meaning to the use of multimedia in psychological
operations. Radio and TV broadcasts, leaflets, and loudspeakers used the themes
of Arab brotherhood, allied air power, and Iraqi isolation to induce large
numbers of enemy soldiers to desert. One of the most effective tactics involved
the dropping of leaflets on a particular unit, informing it that it would be
bombed within twenty-four hours and had to surrender to avoid destruction. Over
a seven-week period, 29 million leaflets in at least 14 varieties were dropped
behind Iraqi lines, reaching approximately 98% of the 300,000 troops.
The
4th PSYOP Group began broadcasting the "VOICE OF THE GULF" radio
network which on 19 January 1991. It operated continuously through 1 April 1991
with more than 210 hours of live broadcasting and 330 hours of prerecorded
programs. A total of 2072 news items were aired along with 189 PSYOP messages.
The VOICE OF THE GULF network consisted of a 50 KW AM transmitter located at
Abu Ali, Saudi Arabia broadcasting on AM 1134; a 10KW AM transmitter located at
Qaisumah, Saudi Arabia broadcasting on AM 1179; a 1KW FM transmitter located at
Qaisumah, Saudi Arabia broadcasting on FM 87.5 and two Volant Solo [now
called Commando Solo} EC-130 aircraft of the 193rd Special
Operations Group broadcasting on AM 690 and FM 88.5 and 87.9.
Of
course like some of the other big wars,
During
Desert Storm the 4th PSYOP Group fielded 71 Tactical loudspeaker teams. These
teams provided support to USARCENT (both XVIII Airborne Corps and VII Corps),
USMARCENT and USSOCCENT. Loudspeaker teams broadcast surrender appeals,
harassment and deception tapes. Most loudspeaker teams had Saudi Arabian,
Egyptian or Kuwaiti linguists attached to execute live broadcasts as the
situation dictated. Loudspeaker teams were also innovatively employed for
prisoner control at the EPW camps with broadcasts designed to accomplish
prisoner pacification and underscore Military Police authority.
One
of the best examples of the successful use of loudspeakers occurred during the
Gulf War. The allied coalition effectively isolated, both physically and
psychologically, a large element of Iraqi forces on
How
successful was the US PSYOP campaign in Desert Storm? The International Red
Cross reported that nearly 87,000 Iraqi soldiers turned themselves over to
coalition forces, most of them clutching the leaflets or hiding them in their
clothing. All incidents of surrender were bloodless. Perhaps the best testimony
to the effectiveness of PSYOPS was given by an Iraqi General when he stated
that: "PSYOP...was a great threat to
troop morale, second only to the coalition bombing campaign."
Today
Psychological Operations are a vital part of the broad range of
IWAC
Note: PSYOP planners need to know the basics of PSYOP CAMPAIGN PLANNING. An Air Force PSYOP / IO planner would view
that planning in context of an AOC’s air missions. An AF PSYOP / IO planner would plan for PSYOP
actions that enhance the air mission, or better support the air support
mission. Unilateral PSYOP planning is
not desirable or executable.
Pg. C1
When Bombs Are Not Enough, The Army's Psyop Warriors
Deploy an Arsenal of Paper
By Richard
For
the leaders of the 4th Psychological Operations Group -- considered among the
Army's most intellectual warriors -- Kirby is a hero. Never mind that he's a
The
weaponry of the psyop soldier includes radio transmitters, loudspeakers and
music, from classical to heavy metal. These elite airborne troops don't drop
bombs on the enemy -- they drop leaflets and crude cartoons urging surrender.
They parachute in, offering bribes, hoping to rat out evildoers like Osama bin
Laden. They set up battlefield copy centers to crank out pro-American
handbills.
"No
one else does what we do," says Col. James A. Treadwell, who commands the
4th Psyop Group, a 1,200-member unit whose slogans include "Win the Mind
-- Win the Day" and "Verbum Vincet" ("The Word
Conquers"). Schooled in marketing and advertising techniques, they are a
brainy subset of the "snake eaters," as the brawny commandos based here
in the scrub pine and strip-club wilds of
Wearing
a maroon beret that designates him as a qualified paratrooper, Lt. Col. Kenneth
A. Turner sounds like a typical "psyop-er" -- they don't go in for
menacing nicknames -- as he patiently explains "the distinction between dissemination
and communication." When he talks about a target, he means an audience.
Turner,
42, commands a dissemination battalion. He speaks French and holds master's
degrees in international relations and military arts and sciences. Like others
here, he considers psychological operations an art with a practical
application. If you can demoralize the enemy and promote defections, the
fighting ends sooner -- thereby minimizing casualties.
"Stop
fighting for the Taliban and live," urges a leaflet designed here.
"Drive out the foreign terrorists," says another.
"That's
what we're all about: influencing people to take certain behavioral actions
that accomplish our national goals," says Turner.
During
the Persian Gulf War, many Iraqi soldiers surrendered clutching U.S.-dropped
leaflets that offered safe passage. "There were special [Iraqi] teams
organized to shoot anyone that was found to be in possession of our
leaflets," Treadwell says. But he and other commanders of the Afghan psyop
war are hesitant to make claims about the effectiveness of their propaganda in
promoting surrenders, saying they haven't yet been able to make assessments.
The
leafleting over
"If
the Taliban are complaining because we dropped this in
In
Many
messages produced here are benign, trying to reinforce the point that Americans
are nice people -- anti-terrorist, not anti-Muslim. "To the honorable
people of
This
is essentially a greeting card to mark Eid al-Fitr, the end of Ramadan. It
depicts a date palm and a bowl of dates -- a traditional food for celebrating
the end of the month-long fasting period.
"Obviously
the target audience is the civilian population of
At
the start of a campaign, the psyop-ers decide which media will be most useful
in getting across their message, "very similar to how a marketing firm
would try to do their business," says Rohm. In
But
many Afghans owned radios, so the psyop-ers began drafting scripts and musical
programming for the "Commando Solo" aircraft circling the region,
broadcasting 10 hours a day. The leaflets relied on simple messages and
graphics because of the population's low literacy rate, but
Messages
must be approved by the brass at Central Command and comport with the
overarching info-war strategy laid out by the White House. Critiques and
wrongheaded suggestions abound. One official objected to a leaflet showing
Afghanistan as a chessboard with bin Laden orchestrating Taliban pawns -- until
the experts here explained that chess is immensely popular in the region and
the image would instantly connect.
Potential
linguistic and cultural gaffes lurk in every operation. In
At
In
"That's
an old issue going back to the Second World War and leaflets that were directed
at the Japanese," explains Robert D. Jenks, another doctorate-holding
civilian analyst at
Over
the years Army psychological operations have spread to the civilian arena.
Because the unit supports peacetime anti-drug and de-mining efforts around the
globe, the old term "psywar" -- accurate when John Wayne made his
Vietnam War movie -- is out of favor now. But the swaggering spirit seems to
live on among the guys who bring strong editing and graphic skills to combat,
who can write radio scripts and leaflet slogans with a certain punch.
In
October, when Army Rangers parachuted behind enemy lines outside
One bore an image of
firefighters raising the American flag. It said simply, "Freedom
Endures."

By Jim Garamone
American Forces Press Service
At any time of the day or night, an Air Force Special Operations Command EC-130E Commando Solo II is in the area of operations and broadcasting news and information to the Afghan people.
The
aircraft fly a variety of missions. In
The
planes are part of the 193rd Special Operations Wing of the Pennsylvania Air
National Guard. They are based at
Army specialists in the language and customs of the area prepare the broadcasts.
The capability allows U.S. Central Command planners to warn the Afghan population to stay away from Taliban and Al Qaeda targets. The broadcasts stress that the coalition campaign is not aimed at the Afghan people, but at the terrorists and their Taliban supporters.
"We
have no wish to hurt you, the innocent people of
Another
broadcast told the people of
The
broadcast went on to explain that the attacks in
Ham
radio operators can listen to the broadcast at 8700 kilohertz, said Air Force
1st Lt. Edward Shank, a spokesman for the squadron. The squadron has
participated in operations in
The name "Commando Solo II" also has meaning. Commando refers to the special operations mission, and Solo refers to the fact that the aircraft can go it alone, Shank said.
bravenet.com